Screengrab via MSG Networks Highlights Matthew Schaefer scored three times in a 5-1 Islanders win over Columbus The 19-year-old landed in company only a few defensemen have ever reached Read below for the hat trick video and what he said about his celly Matthew Schaefer just gave Phil Housley some company. The Islanders defenseman scored his first career hat trick Tuesday in a 5-1 win over the Blue Jackets at UBS Arena. At 19 years and 73 days old, he’s the second-youngest defenseman in NHL history to do it, behind only Housley at 18 years and 320 days. The third goal went into an empty net at 16:08 of the third period, with the Islanders already up 4-1. Schaefer celebrated it like he’d won the Cup, and I love every second of it. Watch the hat trick goal: Hats came flying onto the ice, and Schaefer came back out for a curtain call. His first two goals came at 1:34 of the second and 7:01 of the third, when he shoveled in a Ryan Pulock rebound. Columbus challenged that one for goaltender interference and lost. Only three teenage defensemen have ever scored an NHL hat trick. Housley and Hannu Virta both did it for Buffalo in 1983, and now Schaefer joins them. Schaefer and Housley are the only defensemen with 30 goals before turning 20, and his six multi-goal games are the most ever by a teenage defenseman, one more than Housley. Last month he passed Bobby Orr on the teenage defenseman goals list too. Denis and Jean Potvin were the only Islanders defensemen to do this before him. Denis was the last, back on March 4, 1982. Shannon Hogan asked Schaefer how it felt on MSG Networks after the game. “We were up 4-1 and might have been a little hard of a celly,” Schaefer said. “But I mean, how can I not celly that hard when you guys are in the building?” Catch the full interview: Schaefer was also asked about the names he keeps getting compared to. “All these things, it’s just crazy to hear,” he said. “It’s an honor. I mean, you don’t think about things like that, but obviously when you hear it, it’s pretty cool.” Mathew Barzal, who had two assists, talked after the game about what the Islanders have on this roster: #Isles Mathew Barzal: "We've got the best goalie in the world and the best D-man in the world." — Stefen Rosner (@stefen_rosner) November 18, 2026 Cale Makar might have a word about that second part. Still, nine goals and 24 points through 20 games at age 19 makes it a fun argument. Schaefer now has 10 points during a six-game point streak, and the Islanders are 10-6-4 after winning three straight.